My complaining TA
So, I have a TA that comes in everyday at lunch and 6th period. She is a good kid, a senior who is frustrated with school this year. She is taking a couple of AP classes that are kicking her butt. And feels like everything she’s doing to pass them is not working. In one class, she says that because she didn’t have the prerequisite skills, she’s not succeeding. (and the counselors won’t take her out of the classes). In the other class, she blames the teacher. She said, all he does is talk the whole period and she gets nothing out of it. She doesn’t feel like he “teaches.” She said that he sits at the desk and just talks and then its time for a test and it feels like the test doesn’t represent what he talked about. In addition, she said there is never any homework. ”How am I supposed to be prepared for the tests when there is no homework?” She asked me.
I responded, “its a college level class. what do you expect?” I explained to her that in college, many of my professors simply talked the whole hour, didn’t use powerpoints and the only homework we had was the reading and an essay. The tests covered both the lectures and the reading. So if you didn’t do the reading or understand it, you were screwed.
“But we are in high school,” she said. I kind of agree with her. They ARE in high school and there still need a little hand holding, but somewhere we need to teach them to work independently on their studies. My college experience tells me that they need to learn how sit and listen and take notes and read the text on their own. But I know, what its like for teenagers and their 30 second attention span. Somehow, we at the high school level we need to prep them for college, but meet their developmental and social needs. And honestly, I don’t know HOW to do this . . .
Nevertheless, I asked her, “what does a good teacher do? What is good teaching?”
“The teacher should explain stuff simply. Give us some graphic organizers to help us understand the information, visuals, hands-on, a documentary. We need some visuals. Anything, but talk to us the whole period.”
My response, “You know you won’t get any of that in college. You’ll be lucky if the professor uses powerpoint. You’ve got to learn to make graphic organizers for yourself. To be honest, for me college was a lot of self teaching. When I really got into my major, I spent a lot of time looking up vocabulary or concepts I didn’t understand to make sense of the stuff I was supposed to be studying.”
I didn’t get a college prep education, so I had to work extra hard to get things in college. Reading that should have taken me an hour took be a couple b/c of the work that I had to do to get the prerequisite knowledge. I know my kids are not getting a college prep education, we do spend a lot of time babying them and teaching the tests instead of skills (partly the district’s fault because the focus is RTT and NCLB and the reality is in college especially after freshman year, I rarely bubbled in a scantron.) I don’t want my students to struggle through the first years of college like I did. . . and I keep wondering how do we bridge this gap. . .giving students enough support, but teaching them to work for their education and self research.
