Feedback & Confidence
One of my goals this summer was to rid my home of all the “paper” laying around. . . .you know: bills, stuff from college, notes to self, xerox copies of random stuff. Tonight, I was cleaning out another stack of paper–this stack was from my college days. . . it brought back sooo many memories.
- all nighters
- writers block (absolutely terrible for a History or English major)
- READING, READING & MORE READING
- party allnighters–well, for me it wasn’t much partying. I had a group of friends that I’d play cards or board games with until 3 or 4 in the morning
- dorm life (not that I really miss it, just the people who were there.)
Anyway, as I began to look through the papers, I began to smile and laugh and remember the “good ole days.” As I picked up sheet after sheet, I’d squeal and say, “I remember this. . . .I stayed up all night to write this.. . . I loved this class. . . uh, that professor was narcissistic.” My college days were good. Yes, there were times that I didn’t have money for food or to go out with my friends AND I worked my entire college career. I remember a friend and I gave blood to buy groceries. Her dad found out and it brought the man to tears. The next day, her parents showed up with groceries for both of us and cash. (They knew I didn’t have a father I could rely on and my mother didn’t have any money. She wasn’t even paying my tuition) Yes, those were the good ole days!
I remember my biggest issue in college was a problem of confidence. I did the work and I got As & Bs. But I was never really confident about the work. I never felt “smart.” It was like should have known more than I did. I made up for this with hard work (Today, I make up for it with internet. You mention something I don’t know. . . I google it.) The history department at my university was relatively small, I took the same professors over and over again. And had classes with the same students. I think a few of my professors got to know me pretty well. I participated in class, but I sure lacked confidence in what I was saying. In most classes, I was quiet until someone called on me. . . and when they did, my professors offered feedback that gave me confidence. . . made my words seem insightful.
I was NEVER confident about my writing. (I believe this stems from a teacher in high school who told me I really needed to work on my writing. I had wanted to be a writer someday. . . you know writing books. I don’t believe this teacher intentionally tried to discourage me, she just didn’t encourage me to continue writing.) Tonight, as I browsed through the papers and read my teachers feedback, I began to feel better about my work ALL OVER AGAIN!
From my favorite professor: ”As usual, excellent work,. . . once you realize how bright you are, you will be dangerous.”
“Brilliant. Excellent job weaving the lives of these women together.”
“thoughtful. . . well wrought . . . meticulous” This professor gave me an A- for this essay. This man was INSANE . . .he had a reputation for never giving As and my paper BLED with his marginal comments. I was EXCEPTIONALLY proud of this essay at the time. I remember the SLEEPLESS nights pouring over this paper about More, Menocchio, Martin Luther & Machiavelli. And back then, wikipedia was available to help when I was stuck! It was an assessment of my reading those works that semester.
Today as I look back over these papers, I am overwhelmed and excited by the comments my professors left. I can’t believe how much my professors believed in me and celebrated the work I had given them.
Feedback is soooo important to our students. Grades are not feedback! Unfortunately, I must admit, I take so many grades, it is difficult to offer a true assessment of students’ learning. As I move into this school year, I will make it a point to offer “meaningful” evaluations of their learning. If these comments give me a sense of pride and meaning today, imagine what my words of esteem could do for the teenagers I teach today.





