Book Review: Teach Like A Champion
As I browsed through Lemov’s book (TLAC), I sensed that his book is largely about classroom management with a few teaching strategies thrown in. He’s actually said it in one of the interviews with him-I am paraphrasing, “If you don’t have the students attention, then you can’t teach them.”
There is nothing revolutionary about the book. The techniques presented here are the “basic” building blocks of education and are not new to the education world. The novelty and star quality of TLAC is that Lemov gives the strategies names and organizes them in an accessible way. Most of the principles of TLAC are “old school.” As I began to read more and more, I remember that many of elementary and middle school teachers running their classroom this way-and I graduated over 15 years ago. Thus, it builds more steam to the argument that the traditional pedagogy still works and yields high results. (Hmmmm, ain’t that something?!)
Things about the book that I love:
- The accompanying DVD that shows the strategies in action.
- The organization of the book. It is EASY to browse . . . just picking a strategy here and there read and add to your tool box. It is organized so that there no need to read it cover to cover! Personally, I’ll probably leave my copy in the bathroom or car for a “quick read” after this review. It is one of those books like the Essential 55; you can just flip it open to read a strategy or two and then do something else.
- Lemov provides SEVERAL examples of how each strategy should work through the text and DVD. It is NOT one of the cryptic books in which you can’t figure out how to implement or use the content.
- If implemented, the techniques will give you an effectively run and demanding classroom. Something my students desperately need.
Things about the book that bothered me:
- Although, concepts in the book are universal and can be adapted, it seemed to focus on primary and middle grades. There is little focus on high school. On the DVD, it appeared only 3 secondary classrooms were showcased. Is it because “hooking” students at the primary grades is key to being successful in upper grades? Or that these strategies are not as successful there? Why couldn’t he find more high schools doing great things?
- I feel like the book has been promoted as a teaching strategy book, it is NOT, in my opinion. To me, a teaching strategy is how the content is presented to the student, activities or delivery method. This book seems to be about controlling the learning environment to maximize learning. This is NOT how I want run my classroom. Now, I admit that I am control freak when it comes to my classroom environment. However, there seems to be liberty, freedom and diversity my classroom–it not just a “learning” silence. My students are engaged in discovery and discussion and I am NOT the source of all learning-center-of my classroom. My role is to guide students to learning, not to be the focus of it.
I believe this book is an excellent for first year teachers. Classroom management is one of the biggest issues with first years. I believe if a first year implemented about 15 of the techniques, they would have an extremely successful year. Out of the 49 techniques presented in TLAC, 14 of them are things that I already do in my classroom. Therefore, I can “testify” to the effectiveness of the strategies. MY ADVICE: First year teachers need to graze through TLAC (read a bit here and there)! Do NOT read it cover to cover-it could be overwhelming. Pick only a few things to implement and do those things WELL this year. No one can use them all!
For experienced teacher, this book could give you a few more classroom management strategies to add to your repetoire. In the words of David, “It is always good to sharpen your sword.” As an experienced teacher, I would have been fine with the DVD only-I like hearing the verbiage other teachers use. Nevertheless, I’ve decided that I’ll try to integrate at least 5 TLAC techniques in this books in the upcoming school year:
- No Opt Out-For Q & A, Students must answer the question with a correct answer. Students do not get the option to not answer the question. Lemov gives verbage and options for getting the child to the correct answer. The ones that I’ll probably use most often are guiding the student to the correct answer and allowing another student to answer then come back to the student for the correct answer.
- 100%. This strategy requires teacher to correct students when off task, so that 100% of students are on task the entire class. I love the phrases used by Zimmerli in this clip, “I have Jasmine, but not . .. .” & “Still waiting on 3. . ..on 2. . . now, lets do . . . “
- Name the Steps-This technique is simply giving students steps or process for the content. He suggests no more than six. This is a bit difficult to do with history. However, before reading TLAC, this was something I had planned to do this year. Usually, when I give notes, I give guided notes b/c there is so much content. This year, I had planned to make a change b/c of the results of my AP exam and a transition to SBG. Reading the book for details will be there responsibility and I will be giving “summaries” of history. The plan is to give 1-4 slides of notes in some sort of brief form, analyze a primary source that relates or tell a story, review content. Instead of the long lectures were students are filling in blank after blank. I like the idea of giving them the key points to remember.
- Pepper-Rapid fire of questions during a Q & A review. I usually do Q & A, but its pretty slow. I like the idea of just banging them out one after another. I’d probably need to have them prewritten b/c thats my style. What I like about this that everyone can answer in unison or I can randomly call of various people.
- Call and Response-This technique requires students to answer in unison with an answer or repeat what you’ve said. I used to do this in my classroom, but it had declined over the past couple of years. It reminds me of church-like when the Pastor says God is Good! Definitely, going to use this one more!
***Please don’t feel that this a bash of the book. It is a honest reflection of how I could practically use its contents***
So, I thought it was time to roll out a new look.
Develop an exercise routine. Okay, this still needs A LOT work. I went walking 2 days last week. My problem is that I don’t like exercising. . . I simply don’t like the “pain” that is involved. And I don’t necessarily feel energized afterward. I was thinking about signing up for water aerobics after I completed my swim class. However, my issue with this is that I plan to go out of town for a few weeks and I haven’t exactly determined when and how long, etc.
Okay, so lets talk about this TERRIBLE PD that I went to today. It was simply boring and not engaging at all. It made me think of how my students feel when they are in class. I kept looking at the clock. It was a classroom management course. I expected to walk out with a pad full of ideas of things I could actually implement in my classroom. NOT! It was like the generic course that I took in college. You know, the one where it talked about the aims of classroom management.
Create a parking lot. Basically, this will be a poster on the wall where students can ask questions about anything at anytime using post it notes. I’ve thought about doing it before, but I wasn’t exactly sure how I’d implement it. Now, I decided that students may get up and put notes and questions to me at anytime during the class EXCEPT when I am lecturing. I will place post it not pads all around the room, so that they can have access to them without getting up, so if the question is about the lecture and they are afraid to ask, they can write it down and not don’t forget. I plan to answer the questions in the last 5 minutes of class before the bell rings or at the beginning of class the next day.
In the midst of all the fun, I didn’t realize that we were really loud. That afternoon my principal stopped by to see what was going on. At this point, I had sat down and was cleaning out my desk and the students were choreographing steps to the music. I expected Principal to read me the riot act for not having something more constructive for my students to do–but Principal didn’t, instead Principal watched them for a few moments. I think he was impressed with what they were doing and how orderly they were doing it. Principal left with a nod for us to turn down the music a bit. This was the best last day of school party I’ve ever had AND I had fun, too. Not, just the kids.
When I first became a teacher, I joined
The summer is completely mine, except when I had cheer (but that another topic for another time–btw, i’m trying to forget them). I am not required to do any professional development. I CHOOSE to go to professional development. I go because I have desire to extend my knowledge and become a better teacher. It is important to keep in mind that different states and districts require different things. For example, my state requires that teachers without a Master’s degree complete so many PD hours every three years (like 90, I think). So, the summer is a good time to get those done. Some do it during the school year.