Worst Assignments
These items were consistently mentioned a the worst assignments on my end of the year survey:
- Film Guides–50% of students mentioned they hated the film guides. Most liked the films. It is the guide they detest.
- “students fall asleep quickly when watching them”
- “the guide takes away from enjoyment of the movie”
- “its hard to keep up with the video sometimes”
- “we didn’t learn anything from it”
- Why do I assign film guides? The documentaries/films I use in class often have GREAT content in them. However, my past EXPERIENCE tells me that students tend to go to sleep and miss the main points of the film. I realize that some of my film guides are intensive. For example: my Roots film guide has 100 questions. We watch Episodes 1 & 2 to illustrate/discuss issues of the Middle Passage.
- To be truly reflective, I need to listen to my students comments. I actually discussed this point in detail with my “hellion” class. They said, that the guides had too many questions. So I will do 3 things
- Next year, I will reduce the number of questions on the film guides to see if it makes a difference.
- Co-Teacher started doing something new this year with her film guides and she reported good results. She used the internet to get scene lists/chapter lists for the films shown in class. She used them to make a T-Chart. On one side, students would write the title of the scene. On the other side, they had to write a summary of what happened in that scene or chapter. She paused the film after the scene/chapter to discuss what had happened & make connections. If she couldn’t find a chapter lists, she would find a list of the main characters and as students watched they would identify conflicts or other important information about the character as they watched.
- I will do more excerpts from the films, rather than watching the entire documentary. I will not have my students watch a film and do nothing, that says to them free day and the content is not important. That is not the message I am trying to send.
- Book Work–in my AAH class, I gave book work, maybe 4 times for the entire semester. In my world history, they may have had book work 10 times the entire year. To me, this is NOT excessive.
- “too much reading”
- “its boring”
- Why do I do it? Student need to read the text for background information. Again, in preparation for college students need to be able to read a book and dissect/take notes on the information in it. I can’t tell you how many times I took a test and the info came directly from the text.
- What will I do differently? Nothing. I like book work when its done in moderation. I do it in moderation. And occasionally, I need a day to do paperwork my lovely admins require but have graciously decline me the prep time to do so.
- Projects–25% of students mentioned this as something they hate.
- “They were complicated and boring”
- “we have other classes”
- “this is an elective” *sigh* I don’t even want to discuss this again.
- “because most children don’t try. There are only a few like me who did it”
- “because some students aren’t creative”
- Why I give them? To teach students how to research. If they plan to study anything after high school, research is an important component. Students need to learn how to research, comprehend their research and apply it.
- What will I do differently? Explain the importance of research. Teach more research skills in class. Maybe, offer a lot more in research time.
- Portfolio/Notebook/Binder Check
- “Sometimes we misplace things. that doesn’t mean that were irresponsible and we should lose points for it”
- Why do I require a notebook? Students need to know that a notebook should be kept and used as a study tool. Students need to be taught organization skills. Notebook checks help improve students grades.
- What will I do differently? I need to do some research on how to effectively use notebooks in class. I need to spend more time showing/discussing why they are valuable and how keeping one will prepare them “organizationally” for college or the work place or even managing their own home activities–bills, documents.
- Vocabulary Cards/List–in my AAH class, I made them make vocabulary cards. An image & word must be on the front. Definition on the back. In my WH, students keep their vocabulary in T-Chart form. Word & graphic in the left hand column, definition on the right side.
- I thought they were unnecessary”
- “Pointless & didn’t have anything to do with what we were studying”
- Why do I do it? My students have LIMITED vocabularies. Part of history & reading primary sources is understand what the people are saying. If you don’t understand the words in the text, then you don’t understand the meaning of the document. If I required them to read the document, most wouldn’t understand the context.
- What will I do differently? Find ways to use the vocabulary in class more often. More vocabulary quizzes. Point out and have students highlight when we encounter vocabulary words. Require students to use the words in our discussion.
- Notes--I’m surprised at how many students had issues with taking notes. About 10% of students mentioned that there was too much notetaking.
- “it’s pointless”
- “I didn’t like all of the writing”
- “it seemed as if we took notes everytime we came to class”
- Why do I do it? When you write something down you are more like to remember it. It is a skill they will need for college. AND most of all: IT IS A HISTORY CLASS.
- What will I do differently? Teach more note taking skills. I teach notetaking at the beginning of the school year–the Cornell note style. In my lesson write after the notetaking lesson, I tell them to write what they need. And then I give them a quiz, right after the lesson, with instructions to use their notes. The idea is drill home the value of notetaking. However, this year was NUTS, we lost 20% of our instructional time due to scheduling. Therefore, when I realized I needed to get through my curriculum more quickly, I began to give them “guided notes.” (Basically, its an outline of my lesson and they fill in the blanks as we go along.) And I admit it: I lectured a LOT more this year. Direct instruction was my solution to the “time issue.” So, notes will not go away. I will simply teach why we take notes and make them more productive & useful.
Other students mentioned that they hated things like journals, essays and group work. But these things were minimally listed; therefore, I don’t see them as big issues. I love journals because they add a reflective component to the class. I’d like to do more journal work next year. Maybe, one at the beginning and one at the end of class.

